| Customer Reviews: Average Rating:  Rating : - A Hairy-Chested Selection Anthony Bourdain, the guest editor of The Best American Travel Writing 2008, is determined to shake us up, get our attention, make us uncomfortable. No package tours here, no excursions to familiar places, and believe me, no one is enjoying his travels in this collection. This might well have been subtitled, "Trips to Avoid."
I shouldn't be surprised I suppose. Bourdain's first book, Kitchen Confidential Updated Ed: Adventures in the Culinary Underbelly (P.S.) was horrifying, yet I couldn't put it down. But I found his shtick less compelling with his second book, A Cook's Tour: Global Adventures in Extreme Cuisines, and I didn't bother finishing The Nasty Bits: Collected Varietal Cuts, Usable Trim, Scraps, and Bones. Bourdain is becoming a caricature, a posturing bad boy who thinks he can still shock us by eating bugs.
Still, I never miss each year's Best American Travel Writing collection, and the format is pretty forgiving of the inexperienced guest editor. The series editor, Jason Wilson, selects about a hundred articles from magazines, newspapers, and the web. Then the guest editor's assignment is to choose twenty-five from those. It's difficult, but not impossible, to screw up.
I wouldn't categorize this year's anthology as a screw-up, but it isn't one of my favorites, and I would recommend it only to those who are seriously into adventure tales. Nothing wrong with adventure tales. I have loved Eric Newby's A Short Walk in the Hindu Kush (Travel Literature) with every re-reading. Jon Krakauer's Into the Wild had me hooked from beginning to end. But someone at the Best American Travel Writing forgot that women are adventurous too. A grand total of 25 pages out of this year's 284 pages are written by women.
Some of the pieces from the collection that stood out were Peter Hessler's article about the hazards of driving in China, Calvin Trillin's street food marathon in Singapore, Paul Theroux's swing through Turkmenistan, and Thomas Swick's book signing tours. Of course, it was fun to re-read David Sedaris's account of traveling in business class, but that piece seemed out of place, almost as if the series editor slipped it in with Bourdain's picks, so that readers who might be exhausted from yet another testosterone-fueled trek in a god-forsaken hell-hole would have a brief respite. Thanks, Jason.
+ See Full Customer Review |  |